BBQPickerBBQ smokers, by spec

HomeAll smokers › Charcoal / drum

Charcoal / drum smokers

Bullet (WSM-style), drum and gravity-fed charcoal smokers. Real charcoal flavor; bullets/drums need fire-tending, gravity-fed models run set-and-forget.

Last verified 2026-07-27 · 7 models · cheapest entry: Dyna-Glo Vertical Charcoal (budget tier)

SmokerFuelSizeEaseTierBuy
Dyna-Glo Vertical CharcoalDyna-Glo Vertical CharcoalCharcoal / drumLargeSemi (some tending)BudgetAmazon →
Masterbuilt Gravity Series 800Masterbuilt Gravity Series 800Charcoal / drumLargeSet-and-forgetMidAmazon →
Pit Barrel Cooker ClassicCharcoal / drumMediumSemi (some tending)MidAmazon →
Weber Master-Touch 22Weber Master-Touch 22" KettleCharcoal / drumMediumSemi (some tending)MidAmazon →
Weber Smokey Mountain 18Weber Smokey Mountain 18"Charcoal / drumMediumSemi (some tending)MidAmazon →
Masterbuilt Gravity Series 1050Masterbuilt Gravity Series 1050Charcoal / drumXLSet-and-forgetPremiumAmazon →
Weber Smokey Mountain 22Weber Smokey Mountain 22"Charcoal / drumLargeSemi (some tending)PremiumAmazon →

In one line each: Dyna-Glo Vertical Charcoal — cheap vertical capacity. Masterbuilt Gravity Series 800 — charcoal flavor with thermostat convenience. Pit Barrel Cooker Classic — hang-the-meat drum cooking. Weber Master-Touch 22" Kettle — the kettle that does everything. Weber Smokey Mountain 18" — the most proven bullet smoker ever made. Masterbuilt Gravity Series 1050 — the xl gravity-fed. Weber Smokey Mountain 22" — the big wsm.

Other fuels: Pellet · Offset (stick burner) · Kamado (ceramic) · Electric · Gas / propane · best for a purpose →