BBQPickerBBQ smokers, by spec

Pit Barrel Cooker Classic vs Weber Smokey Mountain 22"

Two popular smokers side by side on what decides the buy. Pit Barrel Cooker Classic is a charcoal / drum smoker; Weber Smokey Mountain 22" is a charcoal / drum smoker.

Last verified 2026-06-11

PropertyPit Barrel Cooker ClassicWeber Smokey Mountain 22"
FuelCharcoal / drumCharcoal / drum
Size classMediumLarge
OperationSemi (some tending)Semi (some tending)
Price tierMidPremium
Best forBeginners, Authentic wood/charcoal flavorCompetition / serious, Authentic wood/charcoal flavor, Large gatherings

Both run semi (some tending). Match the smoker to how much fire-tending you actually want to do.

Check Pit Barrel Cooker Classic price on Amazon →
Check Weber Smokey Mountain 22" price on Amazon →

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Full profiles: Pit Barrel Cooker Classic · Weber Smokey Mountain 22" · best smoker by purpose